David B. Grinberg

4 years ago · 6 min. reading time · visibility 0 ·

chat Contact the author

thumb_up Relevant message Comment

Why All Americans Should Care about Obamacare

Why All Americans Should Care about Obamacare

How much do Americans care about affordable healthcare? Just ask President Donald J. Trump and the Republican-led House of Representatives.

How ironic that after voting over 50 times prior to 2017 to repeal the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare), the House failed miserably last week in attempting to pass a similar bill -- even with the national media spotlight squarely focused on Capitol Hill. This was a conspicuous failure to secure a simple majority vote in the first big legislative test for the new Republican Congress and President Trump.

So what gives?

One would think that after electing a new president and assuming full control of Congress, the Republican Party (or GOP) would have no trouble repealing and replacing the signature domestic achievement of the Obama presidency -- which the GOP has consistently denounced and demonized. In fact, the early so-called "conventional wisdom" in Washington was that such a victory would be the proverbial equivalent to a slam dunk in basketball.

But not so fast.

That's because all the House Democrats -- joined by a handful of Republicans in the self-proclaimed "Freedom Caucus" -- expressed their intention to sink the bill if a vote was held. This was a stinging rebuke to the new Administration and Speaker of the House, Paul Ryan, who had to shelve the vote at the 11th hour. Perhaps this unexpected turn of events should not be so surprising after all. Here's why...

Yes, Obamacare remains controversial despite some initial success. Yet most Americans are wise enough to recognize that tens of millions more taxpayers now have long-awaited and badly needed access to affordable healthcare. There's also the potent point made by the President Obama that America now has the lowest uninsured rate in history.

Most Americans also appear to recognize the intrinsic value and fundamental freedom of universal access to basic health care.

Nonetheless, Americans are still deeply divided on the overall effectiveness of Obamacare in their own lives. These concerns are also being felt by employers, especially small business owners. However, which one of the naysayers out there is ready to give up their own healthcare coverage and pay out of pocket for all medical expenses?

While I’m not an attorney or economist, and therefore won’t attempt to address the legal and fiscal merits of Obamacare, there is still a strong social justice argument to make about the significance of this groundbreaking law. The argument centers on why affordable healthcare should be considered a fundamental freedom and a moral imperative for all Americans, particularly indigent citizens who need it most.

Health Security

f7ab14a5.jpgDoes government have an inherent responsibility that extends beyond national security to basic health security, as part of providing for the general welfare of all citizens? Some proponents of Obamacare go so far to assert that basic health security is indeed a form of national security in the broadest sense of the term.

Access to affordable healthcare is more important now than ever, especially as the chasm over income inequality becomes more gaping nationwide.

It’s worth noting that fundamental change does not happen overnight. It takes time and effort. But significant progress has already been made despite a host of legislative and judicial obstacles meant to derail Obamacare.

It’s important to recall that open access to affordable healthcare is commonplace in most modern industrial democracies worldwide.

America could not have continued to be recognized as the greatest global democracy, and a shining beacon of freedom, had we continued to fail in providing basic health security for all taxpayers.

Prior to Obamacare’s enactment, America had already experienced too many decades of partisan gridlock regarding healthcare. This came at the literal and figurative expense of the neediest citizens among us, those who lacked access to basic healthcare services for themselves and their families.

How could the USA have upheld our nation’s long cherished morals and values by leaving Americans who lack basic healthcare to wither on the vines of desperation? Put simply, America's healthcare system had been stuck in the ditch for too long.

For instance, officials with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) stated back in 2012 that, "The U.S. health system ranks 37th in the world — just behind Costa Rica.” 

While Costa Rica is a beautiful place to visit, would you and your family want to move there for healthcare security? What if that was the only way to access affordable life-saving surgery?

If not Costa Rica, then how about Canada or the other 30-plus countries which had healthcare systems ranking higher than ours before Obamacare became law?

Fortunately, that’s a Hobson's choice no American has to make any longer.


Fierce Resistance

It is not uncommon in American history for groundbreaking laws, like the Affordable Care Act, to be met with fierce resistance at first. Consider Medicare and the Civil Rights Act, for example. Both pieces of landmark legislation went through tough transitions from public scrutiny to public acceptance over many years and decades.

This transition took place from the time the sweeping laws were introduced in Congress, through enactment and national implementation. Medicare was a legislative milestone created by Congress in 1965 via the Social Security Act. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 opened the doors of equal opportunity on myriad levels to tens of millions of Americans who had been left behind due to discrimination. But public acceptance did not come easy.

Similar to Obamacare, opponents of these historic laws predicted gloom and doom for America. Yet, interestingly enough, just the opposite occurred.

As the aforementioned major laws were implemented, their success became more apparent over time. In fact, most Americans came to recognize and accept the intrinsic democratic values and fundamental freedoms provided by Medicare and the Civil Rights Act. This, in turn, helped to make America a better country and a global role model for civil rights and human rights.

Moreover, with the passage of time and the advantage of hindsight, these groundbreaking laws were improved upon by the enactment of critically important amendments. Thus, it’s also likely that Obamacare will follow a similar legislative path of improvement in the decades to come.

If parts of Obamacare are in desperate need of enhancement -- as critics are quick to claim -- then Congress should mend it, not end it.

The fact is that the sky hasn't fallen because of Obamacare, despite the demonizing discourse to the contrary. Rather, for now at least, America has a strong universal healthcare foundation in place to build upon.

B-12 Shot for Middle Class

Among the socioeconomic merits of Obamacare, it has strengthened the middle class by providing access to much needed healthcare that it otherwise lacked. Remember, the cost of paying for the uninsured and under-insured only resulted in skyrocketing insurance premiums for the rest of us.

Additionally, Obamacare provided the struggling middle class with a much needed B-12 shot in the wake of the Great Recession. Workers without health insurance hurt the economy when they and their families face unforeseen severe illnesses.

For instance, according to widespread published reports, about two-thirds of Americans are either obese or overweight, including many children. This is an alarming health trend.

So who pays for it? We all do in higher costs for health-related services. Employers pay for it as an added cost of doing business. These costs trickle down the economic food chain to low-wage workers who can least afford it, causing the substantial gap between rich and poor to widen.

Prior to Obamacare, there were millions of productive American workers and other citizens who could not afford basic health insurance. This broad range of individuals included those who were:

  • Self employed,
  • Unemployed,
  • Part-time workers and temps,
  • Qualified applicants who could not find jobs with employer-provided health insurance, and
  • Employees or applicants with pre-existing conditions.


Therefore, it just makes good economic sense – not to mention common sense – that a physically and mentally healthy labor force contributes more to overall economic prosperity. But the millions of employees who lacked basic health benefits only added to labor costs through increased absenteeism, prolonged sick leave and poor job performance, as well as other economic ramifications for employers.

Obamacare = Freedom

Thus, as efforts to repeal and replace Obamacare continue, let's not forget the most vulnerable among us: those living in poverty and despair for whom affordable healthcare was once a pipe dream.

For these downtrodden Americans, Obamacare represents the very freedom necessary to live an independent and more healthful life.

That means the freedom to see a doctor, freedom to receive needed medical treatment, freedom to obtain prescription drugs, and freedom from the stranglehold of greedy and corrupt insurance and pharmaceutical corporations.

The federal government has always had an inherent responsibility to safeguard and protect the general welfare of its citizenry.  Therefore, it shouldn't be surprising the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld major parts of Obamacare over the years in the face of fierce legal attacks at the lower court levels.

In essence, no American should ever be denied basic medical care due to low income, pre-existing conditions, or other discriminatory factors. The USA is better than that. No American should ever be faced with the grim reality of paying for medical care versus putting food on the table.

That’s simply anathema to the American way.

Note: This post also appears on GovLoop.com ("Knowledge Network for Government").


d89d8e9e.jpgABOUT THE AUTHOR: I'm an independent writer and strategic communications advisor with over 20 years of experience in the public and private sectors -- including work in the White House, Congress, federal agencies, and national news media. I'm also a Brand Ambassador for beBee Affinity Social Network. In addition to beBee, you can find me buzzing around on Twitter, Medium, Thrive Global and LinkedIn.

NOTE: All views and opinions are those of the author only and not official statements or endorsements of any public sector employer, private sector employer, organization or political entity.

thumb_up Relevant message Comment

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #9

I appreciate your valuable feedback, as always, Brian McKenzie. Please answer these five questions if you would be so kind, as I highly value your expert opinions on this important public policy issue... 1) If you, your family members or loved ones had no access to affordable healthcare due to preexisting conditions (or otherwise), would you still be so adamantly against mending/not ending Obamacare? Fix what's broken. Keep what works. 2) Why is every major health-related organization and advocacy group nationwide -- including hospitals, doctors, drug companies, AARP, etc -- against repealing Obamacare if it's as bad as you allege? 3) Why does every Western industrialized democracy have access to universal healthcare for citizens? 4) Do you care if the USA ranks 37 or worse worldwide in successful healthcare? 5) Why are Republicans having so much trouble passing their "repeal and replace" measure? They have majorities in both houses of Congress, plus the White House. Thus, what gives? 6) Bonus Question: do you disagree with Winston Churchill that, "Healthy citizens are the most important asset any country can have"??? Many thanks, again, for sharing your important insights.

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #8

Thanks, as always, for your sharing your important insights -- for which I am most grateful Ali Anani. You all make excellent points worthy of serious consideration. Again, I really appreciate all the commenters below who took time out of their busy schedules to read, comment on, and share this buzz. Thanks to ALL -- please have a wonderful week and keep buzzing!

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #7

Many thanks for sharing your important insights valuable perspectives, which are most appreciated Larry Boyer, \ud83d\udc1d Brand Ambassador. You both make excellent points, as usual. Personally, I just think the USA's spending priorities are on shaky ground if the government spends hundreds of billions of dollars on defense, yet cannot offer affordable healthcare to the most needy citizens/taxpayers among us, especially when every other major industrialized democracy has done so for a long time. cc: Milos Djukic

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #6

Brian McKenzie for sharing your valuable feedback. All constructive comments -- pro, con or indifferent -- are always most appreciated. That's the true benchmark for a healthy and vigorous debate in which all sides are heard -- and we hear you loud and clear, Brian.

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #5

Thanks for the valuable feedback Jim \ud83d\udc1d Cody. It does not appear that Obamacare has much support among the beBee community, at least based on the comments thus far. This just makes it more unbelievable that Congress couldn't pass a replacement bill after 7-years of waiting for a Republican President and majorities in both chambers of Congress. So what will happen next: 1) The House GOP tees up a new bill with some support of Dems to offset the Freedom Caucus? 2) The House GOP tees up a new bill catering more to the Freedom Caucus in order to obtain a simple majority vote for passage? 3) The Senate attempts to pass a new bill and then sends it to the House? 4) President Trump and the GOP Congress decide the best political strategy is to do nothing, let Obamacare "implode" as critics predict, then use it as a campaign issue against Dems in the mid-term elections in 2018? 5) Something else?

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #4

Again, I appreciate everyone's valuable feedback and important insights. I know this is a "hot-button" and contentious issue for which passions run high. But let's please remember to engage in constructive and polite discourse. It's certainly fine to disagree and express strongly held views, in fact I expect that to foster an open dialogue. However, let's please be respectful of one another and refrain from any ad hominem attacks or unproductive comments. Many thanks, as I know we can all agree to disagree in a civil and respectful manner. cc: Donna-Luisa Eversley

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #3

Thanks for your passionate thoughts and important insights Franci\ud83d\udc1dEugenia Hoffman. You all make valid points worthy of serious consideration. However, I would ask the following: 1) What's wrong with mending, not ending, Obamacare? Why not keep the provisions which have worked well and and fix those that have not (rather than repeal and replace)? 2) What does it say that the Republican President and Congress (House) failed to muster a simple majority of votes to pass a competing healthcare bill? 3) Should we just discount the estimated 30 million Americans who couldn't afford basic healthcare prior to Obamacare? 4) Do you agree with guaranteeing health insurance for those with pre-existing conditions (like mental health issues and physical disabilities) and allowing families to keep children on their health plans until a specific age? Again, your valuable feedback and important insights are most appreciated, as always.

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #2

I greatly appreciate your important insights, Lisa \ud83d\udc1d Gallagher, as always. Thanks also for sharing this post on Twitter. You're the best!

David B. Grinberg

4 years ago #1

cc: Javier \ud83d\udc1d beBee

More articles from David B. Grinberg

View blog
4 years ago · 5 min. reading time

How & Why to Spread Your Blogging Buzz on beBee

Blogging is a powerful way to build and showcase y ...

4 years ago · 5 min. reading time

Happy Birthday to Me! Please Hold the Applause

Yesterday was my birthday. · No, I won't tell you ...

4 years ago · 5 min. reading time

Women's History Month: She Made the U.S. Senate 'A Place Where Women Belong'

Did you know that March is Women's History Month i ...