What Good is Good Grammar Anyway?
This post came about thanks to an article that Maggi Kirkbride found, read, and shared -- and tagged me with. You can read it here. Thanks, Maggi!
The article is concerned about correcting another's grammar, which doesn't seem to allow the writer's style to show through. I just don't see it as an either/or proposition. I think we can use correct grammar, at least most of the time, and still allow an individual's style to shine through.
To me, grammar is a bridge between a writer's ideas and a reader's understanding of those ideas. It's a tool that allows for clarity. It has developed over hundreds (thousands?) of years across the world, with the goal of making writing clear to readers. Without some structure, some common agreements, and some consistencies in spelling, usage, and/or punctuation, some writing, like this sentence, would be really tough to read -- see below.
withoutsomestructuresomecommonagreementsandsomeconsistenciesinspellingusageandorpunctuationsomewritinglikethissentencewouldbereallytoughtoreadseebelow
I don't see myself as a pedant at all! I do see myself as a guardian of clarity. I am willing to ignore or overlook a punctuation rule if there would be no confusion or embarrassment as a result of something a client has written. As the article suggests, there is always style to consider. We all have a distinctive voice as writers, and I don't mess with that. I just make sure the i's are dotted and the t's are crossed . . .
Does language evolve? Of course it does! If it didn't, we'd all be talking and writing the way our ancestors did -- or maybe the way Romeo and Juliet did (for English-speaking folks). But there are a few words -- irregardless comes to mind -- that shouldn't show up in professional writing. Not yet, anyway.
And certain words simply are NOT interchangeable. Its is ALWAYS the possessive pronoun; it's is ALWAYS either it is or it has. Your is ALWAYS the possessive pronoun; you're is ALWAYS you are.
Even punctuation rules change over time. Now we're all told to put only one space between sentences and after a colon that sets up a list within a sentence. (It took me more than a year to get my mind to agree, and even longer for my fingers to do it the new way consistently.)
Do I ever end sentences with a preposition? Of course! Some sentences just sound better that way. "With whom are you going?" sounds weird, right? Well, grammatically, it's correct but that doesn't really help. "Who are you going with?" is what we would all say, breaking an old rule that was actually never a rule in the first place.
Do I ever split an infinitive? Yes, sometimes I do, again if the sentence would sound better. The most famous usage of a split infinitive came from the original Star Trek series. Was it done deliberately? I don't know, but I do know the sentence is MUCH better for having that split infinitive. And see the surprising origin of the phrase here.
So while using good grammar is more than a suggestion, there are certainly a few times when we can relax a bit. As long as we're not going to confuse readers, or embarrass ourselves (or our boss, or our company), and we have a really good reason to change up a rule . . . I think it's OK.
BUT.
It helps a lot to know what the rules are before we do that. Many that still exist have a purpose to them: clarity. And that's why I will continue to help others (re)learn the basic punctuation and usage rules of American grammar.
What are YOUR thoughts on using good grammar? When do YOU relax in terms of your own writing?
Articles from Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
View blogGood morning, friends and colleagues! Yes, it's finally Friday again, and I hope as you're heading i ...
It's been quite a while since I last offered you a quiz, so ... · I hope you knock this one off in a ...
Are you familiar with this term? We're seeing evidence of them everywhere on social media, which is ...
Related professionals
You may be interested in these jobs
-
Budget for renovations of a commercial space between 100 and 200 m2
Found in: Handyman CS US - 2 hours ago
Direct apply
beBee Handyman DeCordova, TX, United States FreelanceI am in need of a service to renovate a commercial space in DeCordova, TX with the following characteristics:What type of renovation do you want to carry out? · Complete renovation · Commercial activity of the space or office · Retail business · Size of the property (in square me ...
-
RN-Cardiovascular
Found in: J-Vers US C2 - 2 days ago
Ascension Round Rock, United StatesDetailsSign-on bonus: $20,000 · Department: 6 South Medical Surgical/Telemetry · Schedule: Full time Nights: 7:00pm - 7:00 am, hour shifts per week. Rotating weekends, with 7 day per week availability, weekend and holiday shifts required. · Hospital: Ascension Seton Williamson · ...
-
Part Time Universal Banker- 20 Hour- Sherron Corners BU
Found in: beBee S2 US - 3 weeks ago
Truist Durham, United States Paid WorkThe position is described below. If you want to apply, click the Apply Now button at the top or bottom of this page. After you click Apply Now and complete your application, you'll be invited to create a profile, which will let you see your application status and any communicatio ...
Comments
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #11
Thanks so much, Don Kerr, for sharing the post! I really appreciate it!
don kerr
7 years ago #10
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #9
my pleasure, oh social media guru! Glad to be (bee) here!
John White, MBA
7 years ago #8
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #7
Thank you, Neville Gaunt! Nice to see you here!
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #6
Yes it does, Leckey Harrison!
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #5
Thank you for that, Anees Zaidi!
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #4
I appreciate that, Franci Eugenia Hoffman!
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #3
Thanks so much, Aaron Skogen! Nice to see you here!
Susan 🐝 Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
7 years ago #2
Thanks for sharing my buzz, Javier C\u00e1mara Rica!
Javier Cámara-Rica 🐝🇪🇸
7 years ago #1