Trouble with statistics
For what feels like the majority of my life I have been bombarded with statistics. A set of numbers intended to inform and direct my attention. From the ever-popular 9 out of 10 doctors to the more clinical 30% of the last 43%. You know of what I speak.
But the problem is clear, just how accurate are these numbers? The more you actually look at statistics the more you come to understand just how flexible they are. The smaller the sample rate the greater the potential error, then again the demographic affects the results significantly if you are pooling. The list goes on and on. So just what value does this concept hold?
I have spent my life referring to these numbers as if they were facts or true metrics upon which I could adjust or base decisions on. When in fact they are apparently nothing but marketing tools. This frustrating realization is tantamount to finding out that the tooth fairy isn't real. Who brought me the ever-coveted coins when I left my tooth under my pillow? Now to find out my numbers are just as hypothetical.
Oh, sad day indeed. But now I find myself grown looking once again for that mythical fairy, that warm blanket of numbers. My grasping hands finding instead marketing ploys and guesses. 50 percent of all marriages fail, True? How about that new reality that more and more couples are choosing to ignore the marriage vows altogether. Was that based on the previous statistic? Was that statistic ever accurate?
The problem with statistics is that regardless of the value of the work behind them they are intended to affect our decisions. Statistics are intended to guide our thinking and motivate our choices. But just how valuable are they really. The more I study them more I find that they are just as true as my good friend the tooth fairy.
Please someone tell me I am wrong. I enjoyed my warm blanket.
Blessings!
![25% [rd 1]](https://contents.bebee.com/users/id/12324470/article/trouble-with-statistics/b3f73ff2.png)
Articles from Greg Rolfe
View blog
Fiddling as the world burns · There are days that can feel like we are Caesar fiddling while Rome bu ...

Prevailing winds · It has been said that you should go with the flow. · Watch and see which way the ...

Hold it tightly just not too tightly. · "When people care deeply about the same things, when they sh ...
Related professionals
You may be interested in these jobs
-
The College of Science at Oregon State University-Cascades invites applications for a full-time (1.00 FTE), 9-month, fixed-term, Mathematics and/or Statistics Instructor. · ...
Bend, OR3 weeks ago
-
The Statistical Programmer II generates datasets and graphs to support statistical analyses of data for clinical studies. The position requires knowledge of CDISC standards and statistical software such as SAS.This role involves working onsite at the corporate headquarters in Ali ...
Aliso Viejo1 month ago
-
We are seeking committed, skilled, and customer-focused individuals to join our winning team as Senior Statistical Programmer for our Bridgewater, New Jersey location. · A Master's in Math/Statistics with at least five years experience · ...
Bridgewater, NJ1 month ago
Comments
Ken Boddie
5 years ago#17
Again, what’s with the insults, Zack? People have different opinions based on different experiences. The only thing I have to ponder is my disappointment that you have chosen to turn this into a personal attack.
Greg Rolfe
5 years ago#16
Greg Rolfe
5 years ago#15
Pascal Derrien Dude!!! Sweet!
Pascal Derrien
5 years ago#14
Zacharias 🐝 Voulgaris
5 years ago#13
So, your own experience in a very specific field trumps the meta-analysis of an independent researcher? With such a shallow understanding of generalization, no wonder you advocate the merits of this field! If Stats is so great at adding value, why is everyone shifting towards data-driven approaches to analytics, such as Machine Learning and A.I.? Something to ponder upon.
Ken Boddie
5 years ago#12
I can only assume from your comment, Zack, that you do not understand how statistic is used to good effect in civil/geotechnical engineering design. My view is based on decades of reproducible work well documented in design procedures and published texts. As it appears to differ from your viewpoint and doubtless from your experience in a different environment, please do not make the assumption that my opinion would benefit from improved accuracy.
Zacharias 🐝 Voulgaris
5 years ago#11
Ken Boddie
5 years ago#10
Ken Boddie
5 years ago#9
Ken Boddie
5 years ago#8
John Rylance
5 years ago#7
John Rylance
5 years ago#6
Zacharias 🐝 Voulgaris
5 years ago#5
It's easy to abuse what doesn't click with people. Stats manages that more than any other field, partly because of the way it is taught. It is a highly practical field, yet those who teach it approach it like any other kind of Math, focusing on the formulas and the mathy aspects of it. If someone truly understands Stats, it can be quite useful as a way to understand the data (e.g., through the distribution plots, the statistical tests, etc.). It is being abused, for sure. I wish it weren't like that...
Greg Rolfe
5 years ago#4
Zacharias 🐝 Voulgaris
5 years ago#3
Greg Rolfe
5 years ago#2
Thank you for the link Harvey Lloyd. Yes, indeed some of the Old Testament laws would put quite a kink in branding.
Harvey Lloyd
5 years ago#1