The Anthropomorphization of Ai
TODAY'S POPULAR DISCUSSIONS ABOUT ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND Ai ARE RIFE WITH SCIENCE FANTASY AND LACK ANY CREDIBLE PHILOSOPHY OF MIND…
"The widespread tendency, even within AI, to anthropomorphize machines makes it easier to convince us of their intelligence. How can any putative demonstration of intelligence in machines be trusted if the AI researcher readily succumbs to make-believe?"
― Diane Proudfoot, Dept of Philosophy and the Turing Archive for the History of Computing, University of Canterbury, NZ, Elsevier 2011
When 2001: A Space Odyssey arrived on the movie scene in 1968, the spaceship's fictional central controller, a HAL 9000 (Heuristically programmed ALgorithmic) computer, was given a soft, calm but oddly menacing and distinctively non-human voice. Sci-Fi author Arthur C. Clarke and movie director Stanley Kubrick clearly wanted their audience to make no mistake, HAL might be artificially intelligent, but he (it) was nevertheless a machine. Indeed, that was part of what made HAL so menacing.
In the intervening half-century since the premiere of that film, the lesson was clearly not lost on denizens of research and development in artificial intelligence. For they expend a lot of effort these days in creating machine speech that sounds as human as possible. All while the marketers of Ai apps and devices choose human-sounding names like Alexa, John Paul, Siri, and Watson. Why, do you think that is so?
The easy answer is to make their audio output sound more human and, yes, less foreign and possibly menacing. But I don't really think so. I submit that instead, the objective is to bolster the appearance of human-like intelligence ― which is, in fact, at this point in time, significantly lacking.
"An example I often use in my classes ... is the Kiva system — the multi-robot system doing fulfillment processing in warehouses. Amazon.com uses these robots to bring shelves to the people who pack the boxes after you order something from Amazon."
― Peter Stone, computer scientist, University of Texas at Austin, 2015
Click on the above image to watch a video detailing the operation of Kiva robots that aid in warehouse order fulfillment operations. Pay particular attention, if you will, to the narrative that explains how it all works. Notice how the robots are referred to in terms more appropriately applied to humans and which terms are prima facie not applicable in this situation ― words that imply purposeful action, the exercise of judgment, and intentional decision-making.
Note also how these robots are described in terms that imply artificial intelligence, that is, thinking when nothing about this situation evidences any intelligence whatsoever on the part of the robots.
And finally, notice how some trick photography is inserted that shows "pick and ship" personnel holding out their hands while having the merchandise items appear magically ― no doubt to bolster the feeling of wonderment we're all invited to experience when confronted with the purported marvels of Ai.
This, however, is a case in which wonderment should not enter. It is actually about a warehouse divided into discrete locations laid out on a grid and assigned a number. The locations are no doubt uniquely specified by an x-axis value and a y-axis value. There are pathways left clear for major robot traffic, again designated by X-Y coordinates, and the robots are built sufficiently short to be able to pass under the lower shelves of the inventory "pods", which they pick-up and carry to "pick" stations, where a human worker removes the required item of merchandise from the shelves of the pod, packs it, and forwards it for shipping.
The system's memory tracks where the inventory pods are at any given time, and what inventory remains on each pod at any given time. Making it a larger, but not much more complicated version of a "Traffic Jam" game.
Yet, there is a concerted effort to make it appear much more "intelligent" than it is. And the primary tactic is to anthropomorphize the robots ― attribute to them purposeful action ― rather than recognize them for what they are, essentially dumb machines acting in accord with electronic instructions to move along pre-mapped pathways to given X-Y coordinates on a grid.
When you start paying close attention to the contemporary discussion of Ai, you find it replete with similar examples of projecting "intelligence" into robotic actions that are clearly non-intelligent in any meaningful sense of the term. ― Phil Friedman
Author's notes: If you are interested in further reading on the topic of Artificial Intelligence, you should not miss the following two articles by :
This piece of mine is the fifth in a series on Artificial Intelligence that I am writing from a layman's point of view, one that is not filtered through the eyes and judgment of someone with a vested interest in the hyping of AI. If you'd care to read the other articles in the series, they are:
5) “The Anthropomorphization of Ai”
If you enjoyed this post and would like to receive notifications of my writing on a regular basis, simply click the [FOLLOW] button on my beBee profile. Better yet, elect there to follow my blog by email. As a writer-friend of mine says, you can always change your mind later.
As well, if you feel this piece is of value, please like it and share, share, share it around to your network — whether on beBee, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, or Google+, provided only that you credit me as the author, and include a live link to the original post.
About me, Phil Friedman: With some 30 years background in the marine industry, I've worn different hats — as a yacht designer, boat builder, marine operations and business manager, marine industry consultant, marine marketing and communications specialist, yachting magazine writer and editor, yacht surveyor, and marine industry educator. I'm also trained and experienced in interest-based negotiation and mediation. In a previous life, I was formally trained as an academic philosopher and taught logic and philosophy at university.
Text Copyright 2017 by Phil Friedman — All Rights Reserved
Image Credits: Phil Friedman and Google Images.com
Science and Technology
Articles from Phil FriedmanView blog
THE DYNAMIC DUO OF DUMPING-ON-EVERYTHING IS BACK … EDGIER THAN EVER… · PHIL: Well, Jimbo, it’s been ...
"[By] the use of mooring facilities, boaters don’t unintentionally harm seagrass beds with their anc ...
THE UPDATED AND EXPANDED SECOND EDITION OF THIS WELL-RECEIVED E-BOOK IS NOW AVAILABLE... · More than ...
You may be interested in these jobs
PRN Healthcare Glendale, AZ, United States Temporary
PRN Healthcare is seeking a travel nurse RN Med Surg for a travel nursing job in Glendale, Arizona. · Shift: 12 hours, nights · ~ Employment Type: · Travel · PRN Healthcare Job ID # Pay package is ...
FBI Black Mountain, NC, United States $50,000 - $80,000 per year
JOB DESCRIPTION: · Use your medical and public safety background to become an FBI Special Agent · FBI Special Agents apply their professional expertise and unique skills sets to their work and role e ...
Aureus Medical Group - Nursing Oklahoma City, OK, United States
Aureus Medical Group - Nursing is seeking a travel nurse RN PCU - Progressive Care Unit for a travel nursing job in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma. · Specialty: · PCU - Progressive Care Unit · ~ Start Date: ...