Greg Rolfe

3 years ago · 1 min. reading time · ~100 ·

Blogging
>
Greg blog
>
Predisposition is vast influencer

Predisposition is vast influencer

disposition, tendency,

what are other propensity, predilection,
words for penchant, proclivity,
predisposition? inclination, bias, leaning

 

® Thesaurus. plus

After spending more time than usual reading post and more importantly the comments I noticed a very common thread. People do not read the post. People comment on their biases.

Now I recognize that most of you have noticed this. And I also expect you noticed that people react on their predispositions. What they think prior to reading or in most cases judging a post is the bases of their comment or other reaction. This obviously goes in both directions; agreeing or hating.

Predisposition is makes it very difficult to actually read a post and “hear” what the presenter is saying. Though a greater problem is that it also creates a desire to be justified or the need to rally behind your position regardless of the intent of the post.

If you like tomatoes the current trend to saying tomatoes are very bad for you is offensive. Why? A tomato is a tomato. One person's opinion or indeed an study will not change that. But when we talk about politics or marketing or even hiring practices this becomes even more real. Our inability to actually read a study or an opinion column accurately is becoming rather frustrating at best.

I have even noticed an increase in this style of commenting on the rise lately, possibly due to people having more time to spend on line. But if we have more time cannot we use it to actually read posts and consider what was said? And if it is a “through away” post ignoring it is much more appropriate than commenting anyway.

Our predisposition for or against a topic is a very powerful influence on our thinking and creates holes in how we look at situations. It also has become an excuse to belittle others or lift them up regardless of the true value of their comment or post. Have we become that small?

It is normal to have a position, in fact I expect it is all but impossible not to have one. But should it prevent us from considering other aspects? My own predispositions is as great as any I have noticed so I also expect it has prevented me from hearing the position of others. Ignorance is not a blessing, finding the facts is much more rewarding. Even when they take you where you might not like to go.

If you are taking the time to read something, take the time to hear what is said. Then respond appropriately. What you have to say only matters if it moves the conversation forward. Otherwise it is often best to just walk away. Remember predisposition works both ways.

Blessings.


Comments

Greg Rolfe

3 years ago #7

#7
Lada You indeed have a valid point. Some people posses the ability and I admit the skill, to provide interesting comments though at times at the expense of the post itself. And yes I also have seen a few post with extensive comments usually encouraged by the post originator. But again as you mentioned many of these comments have nothing to do with the post but the development of an idea. Is this a valid use of the post? Perhaps. You never know where a good idea might spring from. Thank you very much for taking the time to add your insight!

Lada 🏡 Prkic

3 years ago #6

Greg, I agree - people often do not read posts before commenting. It is more than evident with long posts, as shown with my last post about the possible future of homo sapiens where some comments were made based on other people's comments. I am not a prolific blogger and write rarely, but when I write, it's not just for putting some thoughts on the screen but hoping for a conversation with readers. I've come to realize that conversing/commenting on social media is not for everyone, especially when it comes to opposing opinions. We all are biased, but how we respond to other views different from our own is what makes a difference. You say that what you have to say only matters if it moves the conversation forward. Many times I've seen comment thread that is more interesting than a post itself. It largely depends on a writer's ability to conduct a long and interesting conversation that makes the thread attractive to new commenters. We've seen comment threads with more than 300 comments on this platform. But also there are comment threads with dozens of thoughtful and on-topic comments that aren't dialogues. Achieving extended dialogue between a reader and an author or between a group of readers with different views and beliefs, in a civil manner, is an art.

Greg Rolfe

3 years ago #5

#3
Hi John Rylance thank you for joining in and adding your insight!

Greg Rolfe

3 years ago #4

#2
Ken Boddie mentioned he is looking for he humor in your posts. And as he mentioned it directs how they respond verses letting the post direct their response. But then I expect I am in no way different. Thank you for your very reasonable and reasoned response!

John Rylance

3 years ago #3

#2
#1 Ken you missed out what draws us, well certainly me, to your comments and your posts your humour. They without exception make me feel I'm laughing with you and you are not laughing at me. Also your poetic efforts. All cases with comments from contributors it's not so much what they say/write it's how they say it. All of which tones in with Greg's predisposition, I am predisposed to read certain Bees's posts.

Ken Boddie

3 years ago #2

Further to my comment below, Greg ... Personally, I take the attitude that all comments, with the exceptions of those from obvious trolls, are happily received and am grateful that the various commentators have not only taken time out of their day to read my post, and perhaps share it, but have formulated a comment, by way of confirmation and thanks. I therefore have always tried to ensure that I respond to every comment on my posts (except from trolls). After all, you never know if a comment, and a response from the post author, may lead to a continuing string and hence an online conversation - a rare event these days. Such continued interaction often permits us to steer the respondent to issues raised in our post that may not have sunk in with them on an initial reading.

Ken Boddie

3 years ago #1

We all have our own predispositions, Greg, which are either acquired or thrust upon us, because non of us are born biased. Some time ago I was exposed to a series of bias tests and, believing myself to be relatively liberal and unbiased, was distraught to see the results when I had undergone just one of them. I wrote on this in a previous post, almost four years ago, at this link: https://www.bebee.com/producer/@ken-boddie/bias-is-only-practised-by-ignorant-people-right I would, however, caution on suggesting that others only comment if it drives the conversation forward. Comments come in many forms. Some are shallow, some are deep, some are restrictive such as "Great Post", some are entertaining or even poetic, some are down right offensive (ie from trolls), and some, as you say, may seek to drive the commenter's personal agenda while being perhaps sparked by the subject matter rather than contributing to it. They are all, however, responses to what we, as post authors, write and, without the trigger of our posts, some of these comments may not have appeared on line. We are living in a world of deteriorating attention spans, when many long posts may not be read in their entirety, and when it is becoming more rare for people to actually comment on line.

Articles from Greg Rolfe

View blog
1 year ago · 1 min. reading time

I am requesting your input · I have a question to put before you. · In an attempt to explain the que ...

1 year ago · 1 min. reading time

Hold it tightly just not too tightly. · "When people care deeply about the same things, when they sh ...

1 year ago · 1 min. reading time

Finding you balance · When a child is learning to walk, they have this tug of war with gravity. · Th ...

Related professionals

You may be interested in these jobs

  • CELESTAR

    Mid-level Intelligence Management Specialist

    Found in: Talent US C2 - 5 days ago


    CELESTAR Tampa, United States

    Mid-level Intelligence Management Specialist (Logistics Support) - CENTCOM · Minimum Education: HS Graduate or Equivalent Clearance Level: Top Secret - SCI - Poly ID: 1 Location: Florida, Tampa Description · Celestar Corporation is seeking a Mid-level Intelligence Management ...

  • MedUS Healthcare

    Travel Nurse

    Found in: Talent US A C2 - 1 week ago


    MedUS Healthcare Chillicothe, United States Freelance

    MedUS Healthcare is seeking an experienced Medical Surgical Registered Nurse for an exciting Travel Nursing job in Chillicothe, OH. Shift: 3x12 hr days Start Date: ASAP Duration: 13 weeks Pay: $2098 / Week About MedUS Healthcare: · MedUS Healthcare, formerly Axis Providers, is a ...

  • Phaxis

    Travel ER RN

    Found in: Lensa US P 2 C2 - 5 days ago


    Phaxis Wichita, United States

    Phaxis Travel Healthcare has an immediate opening for an ER RN in Wichita, KS I will work closely with you to help plan your next big move in your career. I actively work on your behalf to help you find the job of your dreams, whether close to home or across the country.From subm ...