American Grammar Checkup: Why We Should Use the Oxford Comma
An exchange with one of my readers on Medium in The Writing Cooperative β Joe Varadi β prompted me to write this follow-up to my The Devil is in the Details post about details we often miss as we're copyediting or proofreading our own work.
Part of our discussion was about the American rule of always placing periods and commas inside / in front of / before the final quotation marks, even weβre only quoting the last word(s) of the sentence. As many have mentioned over the years, it does look odd, and no, it is not intuitive. And honestly, it makes no sense.
But, as many have also said, βIt is what it is.β
Several other readers also mentioned the Oxford comma, so Iβm hoping after reading this article that they β and maybe YOU, too β will see why I strongly suggest we form the habit of using it to stay safe as writers. That way we will always know that the ONE time we might really need it β itβll be in our sentence.
Hereβs one of the best memes I ran across in the last year on this topic.
It clearly shows that if we leave out the Oxford comma, many will see the parents as Superman and Wonder Woman.ΒBut, surely, the real intent of the sentence is to say that the writer has multiple heroes: the parents, Superman, and Wonder Woman.
Now, will the earth crumble and shatter if we leave the comma out? No, but our readers may laugh and wonder what we were thinking if we write anything like that. And one of my goals in writing is to make sure my readers are not confused by what Iβve written. The Oxford comma at least protects me from one type of confusion I could create.
Not persuaded yet? How about this one below? As written, is it possible that someone could be confused about the number of positions that are available?
Several positions are available: account manager, maintenance supervisor, receptionist and typist.
Yes, of course, it's terrible writing, but it happens everywhere. And one thing Joe Varadi suggested correctly was that many times, we could just rewrite our sentence so that the Oxford comma wouldn't be needed for clarity, a point I totally support. Sometimes that's the easiest and best solution.
The one above could easily be rewritten: We have four positions available: account manager, maitenance supervisor, receptionist and typist.
Even though I would still use the comma after receptionist, it wouldn't be needed for clarity; writing how many positions are availble makes the sentence clear.
Thanks, Joe Varadi, for your suggestions! I really appreciate it when readers have points to make I might not have thought of. That's how we all learn, right?
What are YOUR thoughts on this?
BONUS: For a few more funny memes, see below.
https://www.buzzfeed.com/adamdavis/the-oxford-comma-is-extremely-important-and-everyone-should?utm_term=.ucxz5L3AV#.iqD0BKOMq
And if this post helped you in any way, please consider sharing it with your connections so they may learn, too. Β
Articles from Susan π Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
View blogGood morning, friends and colleagues! Yes, it's finally Friday again, and I hope as you're heading i ...
The Internet is a wondrous place, especially for those of us who grew up long before it was even tho ...
Iβm not the first, and Iβm sure I wonβt be the last here on LI (or any other professional platform) ...
Related professionals
You may be interested in these jobs
-
TIG Welder 2nd Shift
Found in: Lensa US 4 C2 - 1 day ago
PDS Tech East Granby, United StatesAre you ready to spark your career as a TIG Welder? We're looking for talented individuals to join our dynamic team in East Granby, CT If you have a passion for precision and love working with exotic metals, this opportunity is tailor-made for you Β· + Type: Full-Time; Temp-Hire Β· ...
-
Biomedical Equipment Tech I
Found in: Talent US A C2 - 3 days ago
InsideHigherEd Burlington, United States Administrative Jobs ,Advertising/Posting Title:Biomedical Equipment Tech I Β· Diversity Statement:The University is especially interested in candidates who can contribute to the diversity and excellence of the institution. Applicants are encouraged to include in their cover letter information about ho ...
-
Site Procurement Manager
Found in: Lensa US 4 C2 - 1 day ago
SCM Talent Alachua, United StatesSite Procurement Manager Β· The Site Procurement Manager manages procurement operations that build value-driven supplier partnerships focusing on cost, delivery, and quality in support of local site business strategies. He/she develops and follows structured processes to conduct ...
Comments
Joyce π Bowen Brand Ambassador @ beBee
6 years ago #6
I see so few use it now
Susan π Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
6 years ago #5
Why do you question it, Joyce \ud83d\udc1d Bowen Brand Ambassador @ beBee? Curious.
Joyce π Bowen Brand Ambassador @ beBee
6 years ago #4
Susan π Rooks, The Grammar Goddess
6 years ago #3
Well, , I don't see any reason for the comma there; I think we all know that the Securities and Exchange Commission is one complete entity, having nothing to do with the Department of Labor. I'd want to see the whole sentence before being sure, however.
David B. Grinberg
6 years ago #2
John Rylance
6 years ago #1